Sean’s Public Notebook

The GUI was invented as a tool for thought

The heritage of the GUI is a tapestry woven from ideas pulled from multiple contributors. But it was really Alan Kay and the Learning Research Group (LRG) at Xerox PARC, working on Smalltalk (on the Alto) in the early 1970s, who laid the lion’s share of the foundation of the GUI as we know it today. Smalltalk borrowed multiple ideas from earlier implementations (e.g. direct manipulation from Sutherland, or menus from Ambit/G, or Engelbart’s mouse), but it also expanded on them and packaged them together into the modern GUI as we know it today.

Smalltalk thus became the proving ground for most of the ideas of the modern GUI. It was in Smalltalk where we find the first overlapping windowing system (a “shower thought” from Kay implemented buy LRG team member Diana Merry using Dan Ingalls’ “BitBlt” technology). Smalltalk also was the first environment to demonstrate the contextual menu. And Smalltalk demonstrated many other shared firsts such as scrollbars, modeless windows, direct editing of live running code, and the multi-paned “browser” (similar to the macOS Finder’s column view).

But the driving idea behind all of this invention was that the GUI needed to be a tool for thought. LRG was relentlessly focused on making the vision of the Dynabook a reality, which required that the computer be approachable and usable by children for their own exploration and thinking. Each of these inventions served this purpose. As Kay wrote in The Early History of Smalltalk:

The big shift that consolidated these ideas into a powerful theory and long-lived examples came because the LRG focus was on children. Hence, we were thinking about learning as being one of the main effects we wanted to have happen. Early on, this led to a 90 degree rotation of the purposed of the user interface from ”access to functionality” to “environment in which users learn by doing.” This new stance could now respond to the echos of Montessori and Dewey, particularly the former, and got me, on rereading Jerome Bruner, to think beyond the children’s curriculum to a “curriculum of the user interface.”

Emphasis on the environment in which users learn by doing. Bruner was highly influential on Kay, which led him to assert (paraphrasing here) that Good interfaces should support all three of Bruner's modes of representation.

Unfortunately, the GUI’s origins as a tool for thought have largely been overlooked in today’s computing environment. Most people today see graphical interfaces only as systems to support ease of use and discoverability, even though well-designed Interfaces can enable entirely new modes of thought!

References

Kay, A. (1993) The Early History of Smalltalk.