Epistemic actions are taken to think, not to progress toward a goal
Kirsh and Maglio distinguish pragmatic vs. epistemic actions: A pragmatic action is an action one takes in order to accomplish a particular task, usually to bring a person closer to their goal. An epistemic action, on the other hand, is an action a person completes in order to think through something by uncovering previously hidden information, or information that would be harder to compute “mentally.” And it turns out that Experts manipulate and perform more epistemic actions than non-experts in many situations.
What’s important here is that epistemic actions are not always seen by actors as useful towards a particular goal in the moment they undertake them; they are exploratory by nature! Cognition can depend on action, rather than intelligent action always depending on cognition first. That is: Epistemic actions can often precede cognition because a person may take an action first in order to understand a problem space, or unveil information, before devoting the energy to think about what to actually do next. This is generally in line with Kirsh’s broader work on distributed cognition, in which agents offload cognition into the world rather than make mental models and depend solely on thinking “in the head.”
But this raises a question I don’t have a good answer for: Is the action truly separate from cognition at all? Both embodied and distributed cognition might question the very notion of precedence here since action and “thought” could all be wrapped up into a single cognitive act.
References
Kirsh, D. and Maglio, P. (1994) On Distinguishing Epistemic from Pragmatic Action.
Links to this note
-
Action can precede cognition
…But Kirsh and Maglio have argued that sometimes people will engage in epistemic actions—actions they undertake in order get a better sense of the world, but without any pragmatic movement towards a concrete goal—before they think about a problem. Action can thus alter the way cognition occurs (just as much as the inverse) if it unveils information that would previously be hidden or unavailable if the…
-
Experts manipulate and perform more epistemic actions than non-experts
Epistemic actions are taken to think, not to progress toward a goal. In their paper, Kirsh and Maglio use an extended example of Tetris to show that experts tend to perform more epistemic actions than non-experts. Advanced Tetris players, for instance, will manipulate a piece in space as it falls to see where it should fit, rather than try to mentally envision the various rotations in…
-
Interfaces can enable entirely new modes of thought
…(Epistemic actions are taken to think, not to progress toward a goal.) References