Sean’s Public Notebook

Digital collaborative environments tend to be neat

David Kirsh notes that physical office environments can generally be placed somewhere on the “scruffy” to “neat” spectrum in terms of how they are organized. Some offices are sparse and clean and orderly (neat), others are often messy, cluttered, and in disarray (scruffy).

Each of these arrangements has advantages and disadvantages. For instance, There are more activity entry points in messy (scruffy) spaces.

But I notice that in digital or online environments, the default organization scheme tends towards “neat” on this spectrum. In fact, it’s often unavoidable. Why is this? Is this the result of implicit bias by interaction designers who tend to prefer neat, organized environments? Is this the result of natural constraints imposed by the computing environment?

In working on Muse Studio, researchers at Ink and Switch seem to have made a similar observation.

Creative people tend to nest. A professor in their classroom, a writer in their home office, a woodworker in their shop, an artist in their studio—these spaces are full of work surfaces like desks and drafting tables, drawers and pegboards full of tools, pinboards and chalkboards and whiteboards, scraps of paper, photos, books, printouts, works-in-progress, post-its, and more. They are messy, informal, mixed together, freeform, and personal.

Compare these to our digital workspaces: what we see on the screens of our computers, tablets, and phones. Lists and grids of items, neatly arranged by the computer (perhaps sorted by date or name). Media types are often siloed (text notes in one place, web pages in another, PDFs and their highlights in still another) and difficult to view together. We don’t entirely choose what goes into our workspaces and things don’t tend to stay where we left them. In short, digital workspaces are structured, sterile, and impersonal."

Physical space can act as scaffolding for creative work, but so can virtual spaces. Indeed, this is one of the primary functions of virtual spaces—the offloading of cognition into the environment to aid in creative thinking. But one of their secondary functions is to inspire, to allow those who work within the space to make connections between disparate ideas.

If all of these digital spaces are “neat,” then making these connections becomes challenging because The opportunity for serendipitous encounters in many digital information spaces is low.

References

Kirsh, D. (2001) The Context of Work.

McGranaghan, M., Keskin, G., Wiggins, A., & Roggatz, J. (2019, April 4). Muse: Designing a studio for ideas. Ink & Switch. https://www.inkandswitch.com/muse/